[ That surprisingly earns Witch a smile? A normal, pretty neutral one, but a smile nonetheless. ]

Yeah. You did. That's a great first step.

Witch— [ He pauses, as though considering something, but shakes his head to erase the thought. Considering this guy's supposed power, he probably already knows Cain can't see, but no reason to say it out loud. ]

If the rest of the steps are too much for you to handle on your own, just tell us. Someone here will probably be able to help you—if those plaques are right, then you have a lot of talented and capable people here.